Saturday, March 21, 2015

Dinesh Kamath's Editorial 'Use carefully the right to freedom of speech' that was published in Newsband

Use carefully the right to freedom of speech
In the past the writers who wrote the truth about important people would become the target of anti-social elements. Today the television channels are targeted. Freedom of speech and expression has seldom been under so much threat. Example is the bomb attack on the office of Tamil TV channel Puthiya Thalaimurai. It indicates the growing intolerance in our society to new heights. This is a challenge to the secular and tolerant ethos. This is violence perpetrated to intimidate liberal sections of society from debating or questioning on important issues. The full force of the law should be used to rein in elements out to intimidate media and society.
The thali is a neck ornament worn by Hindu women as a symbol of marriage and a living husband. The show debated whether battered or abandoned wives still need to wear it. As a religion, Hinduism has always shown a philosophical indifference to forcing rituals and symbols on its adherents. But like in every other religion, Hindu religion too has intolerant fundamentalists.
The right to protest or expressing difference of opinion by peaceful means should be recognized for all whether they are Hindus/Muslims/Sikh/Jain or of any faith or organization. Violence should be shunned to express dislike or difference of opinion by all and sundry. Harsh words sometimes also sound like violence - it is better to avoid them for the good of all.
Protest against such types of TV shows, article or some things like that should be peacefully done. Ours is a democratic country and all have right to protest or support. It is very unfortunate to see fundamentalists resorting to violence to display the differences between them and liberals.
Intolerance comes from ignorance. Whether we can as a society educate people on common sense, would be a good question. As for religion, it has long ago disappeared. What is left now, is really political parties in the guise of religion.
Hindu traditions or practices have become a soft target for media persons, film directors and activists seeking instant fame. Are topics such as 'veils', multiple legal wives taboo? Would Censor board have cleared PK had the film portrayed Minority community practices?
It is true that sometimes, people in the name of Freedom of Speech tend to talk unwanted things. Freedom of speech does not mean that it can offend sentiments of people. If they believe something is not required they are free not to follow that. Why call for a debate on that? It is just to invite trouble and become popular with the help of controversies that channels want to get the much needed TRP's which is really absurd.
If freedom of speech was the basis of this assault, can any of these publishing house have guts to talk on Islamic tenets. And then let us see how political parties jump to protect minority.

At the same time, no right thinking, peace loving and law abiding citizen will support or concur with violent reactions against someone writing or speaking about his/ her views on a variety of matters that affect the society at large. The bomb attack on the TV channel is deplorable and calls for strict action as per law. That said, we all must remind ourselves that freedom of expression is not absolute and can be limited when it conflicts with other rights. The limitations should relate to the rights or reputation or faith of various social groups, national security, public order, public health and morals. These limitations should be an integral part of Freedom of Expression. There is a saying "Whatever you leave unguarded, guard your tongue; otherwise grave errors of speech and the consequent misery will ensue."

No comments:

Post a Comment