Tuesday, July 29, 2014

Dinesh Kamath's Editorial 'An extremist act in a democratic country' that was published in Newsband

An extremist act in a democratic country
Shiv Sena MP of Thane Rajan Vichare forced Arshad, a catering supervisor at the IRCTC canteen in Delhi’s New Maharashtra Sadan, to eat a chapati during his Ramzan fasting period last week. This is clearly a high-handed approach of Vichare and his colleagues from the Shiv Sena.
It is high time Shiv Sena stopped specialising in using strong-arm tactics to silence those who disagree with it. This is an extreme and unacceptable behaviour. The Sena has violated the law of the land with impunity time and again. This act was performed in spite of the fact that Arshad was in uniform, displaying his name badge. This act has been captured in television footage.
It is now clear that in India the powerful still enjoy impunity. The elected representatives are supposed to set an example for people by their behaviour, The distress caused to a Muslim employee by the callous, even if not deliberate, disregard of his religious sensibilities is apparent. It was a very bad act, and in poor taste. The MP had many other ways to express his disapproval of the quality of food served in the Maharashtra sadan. The supervisor could have been summoned and questioned and asked him to take corrective action. Now the incident has been blown out of proportion to give it a communal colour and create a divide in the society and the press is playing a major role in this negative publicity.
What needs to be looked into is whether such behaviour is more common than we think and is present across all levels of society. We can conjecture that this is exactly what a home owner would do to his/ her servant, a father to a son, husband to a wife or teacher to a helpless pupil. It is only from such a society that such representatives attain high office.
Powerful actors drive expensive cars and kill pedestrians and aim sharp rifles and shoot endangered species. Rich sons of former ministers get bail, organize huge rallies, and destroy property. A well-connected actor gets away with murder. High ranking officers routinely violate subordinates. It may or may not have any connection with religion and caste but merely the projection of the power of wealth, brute force, and official influence of the perpetrators. Media should focus on specific individuals in each case in order to isolate them from their uninformed followers.
For change to happen, we will need more sensitive and humble people coming into politics and not the current brazen lot, only when this changes, Indian Politician scenario is going to change. This change has to happen at one constituency at a time and not from "New Delhi". We tend look at "New Delhi" for solution to all our issues, where is the local responsibility.

While this incident by this MP is condemnable without question, Muslims should stop using this to further add to their "victim-hood" mentality. As for Gujarat riots, as horrible as it was, it was not started by Modi. It was started by the barbaric act of burning alive defenseless women, children and old people in the train compartment. Had this horrible incident not occurred, there wouldn't have been any riots, not that the riots are justified.

No comments:

Post a Comment